This week on the Classic Mysteries podcast, we have a return engagement for one of Agatha Christie's finest investigators, Miss Jane Marple, of the little village of St. Mary Mead. I must say that I often prefer the Miss Marple books to the Hercule Poirot stories. But why set them up as rivals? Instead, let me share with you a review I wrote of one of my favorite Miss Marple books: The Mirror Crack'd From Side to Side (1962). This audio review was done for the Classic Mysteries podcast several years ago. Here's a transcript - as usual, slightly edited:
- 0 -
Miss Marple looked shocked.
“I don’t know why you should assume that I think of murder all the time.”
“Nonsense, Jane. Why don’t you come out boldly and call yourself a criminologist and have done with it?”
“Because I am nothing of the sort,” said Miss Marple with spirit. “It is simply that I have a certain knowledge of human nature – that is only natural after having lived in a small village all my life.”
Those are the words of Miss Jane Marple, probably Agatha Christie’s second-best-known detective. Although she’s not really a detective – or a criminologist, as she says. It’s just that she has had a great deal of experience in sizing people up in the small village of St. Mary Mead, where she lives. And that experience frequently has allowed her to solve murders – and other serious crimes – where the police have been heading in the wrong direction. We have another example of that ability in action today in The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side, by Agatha Christie.
The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side was the eighth of the twelve novels Agatha Christie wrote about Miss Marple. By the time of this book Miss Marple is definitely feeling her age. She still lives in her small house in the village of St. Mary Mead, putting up with a companion-nurse who insists on treating her like a rather feeble – and even feeble-minded – old woman. Being Miss Marple, she won’t sit still for that. So, escaping her house one day, and walking through the new housing development which is so changing the nature of her beloved village, she takes a fall. She is rescued by one of the residents, a kindly (if rather officious and self-preoccupied) woman named Heather Badcock.
At the same time, Gossington Hall – a house well known to Miss Marple from earlier adventures – has been sold to a movie star, Marina Gregg, and her husband. They invite several important townspeople to their house for a party to benefit a local charity – and Heather Badcock, who is active in that charity, is one of the guests. As Mrs. Badcock introduces herself to Marina Gregg, who is standing at the top of the stairway to greet her guests, another guest – one of Miss Marple’s friends – notices a most unusual thing: Marine Gregg suddenly stares, apparently over Mrs. Badcock’s shoulder, at something or someone she sees on the stairway. As it will later be described to Miss Marple, it reminded observers of Tennyson’s poem about the Lady of Shalott – hence this quote:
Out flew the web and floated wide;
The Mirror crack’d from side to side;
‘The curse has come upon me,’ cried
The Lady of Shalott.
And while it is not at all clear what produced this stricken, even cursed look upon Marina Gregg’s face…within minutes, there is a murder. And, fairly soon after that, Scotland Yard detective Dermot Craddock, who takes over the investigation, must decide whether perhaps the wrong victim has been murdered.
The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side was published in 1962, when Agatha Christie was 71 years old – and the result is one of the best of her later novels to feature Miss Marple. It’s really a work of pure armchair detection, for Miss Marple deduces the correct solution to the mystery based solely on what others tell her and, of course, her skill at understanding human nature, as developed in a very small village. She never visits the scene of the crime herself until the very end of the book, when she goes to Gossington Hall to explain the truth about what had happened.
For those who believe that Christie created great plots, but never wrote about great characters, this book may make you rethink that idea. Many of the characters – Marina Gregg, her husband, Heather Badcock, and others – are strong enough to make readers care about what happens to them. And Miss Marple – more vulnerable to her own advancing age than she likes or will admit – is a very sympathetic character, at least as far as I’m concerned. The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side is a pretty dark book for Agatha Christie – very little in the way of a happy ending. But, as is usually the case with Christie, it is carefully plotted, with clues placed throughout the book that should lead the careful reader to figure out the real solution before Miss Marple reveals it. That is, it should lead the reader there – but probably won’t. I do think you’ll like it.
- 0 -
You are welcome to listen to the original audio review by clicking here.
Next: Man of Two Tribes, by Arthur W. Upfield.