Or follow that Dickson, anyway. I noted in my review of And So to Murder this week that it wasn't really my favorite Sir Henry Merrivale novel written by John Dickson Carr writing as Carter Dickson. A quick check online shows me that two of my favorite H.M. novels are still available, both in print and electronic editions.
The Judas Window is nothing short of brilliant - what seems to be a totally impossible crime (with an obvious candidate for the gallows) is de-mystified by H.M. - who keeps reminding readers throughout the book that the crime was simple and relied on a Judas window. And what is a Judas window, you may ask? Read the book...
Also still available is The Plague Court Murders, which was the very first Merrivale novel. The impossible crime is quite good, but it is the eerie atmosphere which really carries the book; it wouldn't have taken much to turn this into a great ghost or horror story along the lines of M.R. James, but it's a mystery instead - and I certainly didn't follow the cleverly hidden clues while I was reading it!
I've written about both before - The Judas Window is here, and The Plague Court Murders is here. Take your pick - you can't go wrong with either choice.
Les - I have to agree with you about The Judas Window as far as the H.M. series goes. At the same time I plead guilty to a slight preference for the Gideon Fell stories (I think The Hollow Man/The Three Coffins is the best of those). But I agree that you really can't go wrong with those two H.M. novels.
Posted by: Margot Kinberg | June 21, 2014 at 02:30 PM
Margot, I agree with you - and I think "The Three Coffins" is probably Carr's best, overall. But I also enjoy many of the H.M. books, and I think "The Judas Window" and "The Plague Court Murders" are among the best of those.
Posted by: Les Blatt | June 21, 2014 at 03:35 PM