I suppose that it takes a certain amount of recklessness to produce a list and anthology of "All-Time Favorite Detective Stories," but, as the editor, Rochelle Kronzek explains, these are remarkable stories worth reading.
More than sixty years ago, in 1950, Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine invited a panel of mystery critics and authors to come up with a list of what they would consider the best detective stories ever written. The list of 12 stories appeared in the July, 1950, edition of the magazine.
Now, Dover Publications has issued an anthology of those 12 stories, complete with an excellent critical introduction by Kronzek. It's a pretty amazing list of stories and authors:
- Thomas Burke: The Hands of Mr. Ottermole
- Edgar Allan Poe: The Purloined Letter
- Sir Arthur Conan Doyle: The Red-Headed League
- Anthony Berkeley: The Avenging Chance
- Robert Barr: The Absent-Minded Coterie
- Jacques Futrelle: The Problem of Cell 13
- G. K. Chesterton: The Invisible Man
- Melville D. Post: Naboth's Vineyard
- Aldous Huxley: The Giaconda Smile
- H. C. Bailey: The Yellow Slugs
- E. C. Bentley: The Genuine Tabard
- Dorothy L. Sayers: Suspicion
Are these, in fact, the best ever written - even from the vantage point of 1950, when the list was compiled? I can't say they are THE best - but they certainly are AMONG the best. Sherlock Holmes, Father Brown, The Thinking Machine, Uncle Abner, Reggie Fortune - not bad, not bad at all. Every one is worth your time and attention. The book is the subject of this week's podcast review, and you may listen to the full review here.
This collection of vintage short stories is my entry for this week in the My Reader's Block Blog Vintage Mysteries Reading Challenge - and, once again, if you haven't checked it out before, do so - there is much to enjoy there!
Comments