In "Case for Three Detectives," the book reviewed on our podcast this week, a lot of the fun is generated by the fact that three great amateur detectives - we are assured they are amateurs and much smarter than the police! - come up with brilliant - but wrong - solutions to the mystery.
In doing so, those detectives really are offering a homage to E. C. Bentley's wonderful "Trent's Last Case." Published in 1913, this book features a brilliant amateur detective who, in the course of a complex and highly enjoyable mystery, manages to come up with a dazzling and ingenious solution to the crime, marred only by the fact that he is totally wrong. I reviewed it on the podcast more than two years ago, but you can still listen to the review here.
According to the blurb for the Dover edition of this book (see the link above), Agatha Christie called "Trent's Last Case" "one of the best detective stories ever written." Dorothy L. Sayers was another fan. The Dover edition also features an excellent and informative introduction by Douglas G. Greene, who is widely recognized as an authority on classic mysteries and the author of the definitive biography of John Dickson Carr. The story itself is clever, occasionally funny, and a fair puzzle mystery. The Dover edition is very inexpensive, but there's also an electronic edition, for those of you with Amazon Kindles; it's accessible through the linked page where you can read about the Dover edition.
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.