Sometimes an author can be too successful in coming up with an ingenious murder plot. Apparently, that happened to Arthur W. Upfield, the author of a series of fine classic mysteries set in Australia and featuring half-caste Detective-Inspector Napoleon Bonaparte, or "Bony" to his friends.
Upfield spent a fair amount of time wrestling with a plot idea for one of his early novels, "The Sands of Windee," which was published in 1931. He was looking for a plot which would allow Bony to tackle what he would call "the perfect murder" - a murder in which there was no body - and, so, no proof a crime had been committed.
While working on the plot in the late 1920s, he had a number of conversations with authors and other friends and acquaintances about his ideas. Unfortunately, one of the people he spoke with, an itinerant stockman named Sonny Rowles, apparently decided to put that perfect murder plot into operation.
Rowles apparently carried out three murders in 1929 and 1930, known as the "Murchison murders," but they were imperfect enough for him to be caught, tried and executed. Upfield had to testify at the trial about his conversations with Rowles, showing that Rowles had known about the perfect murder plot and how it worked. Wikipedia has a fascinating article with full details on the crimes and the Upfield connection.
As for "The Sands of Windee," it's an excellent book, though out of print; Amazon's second-hand affiliates may be your best bet for finding it.
I think it was 'Snowy' Rowles not Sonny. It looks like someones made a film on Upfield & Snowy, I found a behind the scenes video on Youtube ... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Z92BbllZUQ
Posted by: Bella Pooley | May 13, 2009 at 05:13 AM
Whoops! You're right. It is Snowy, not Sonny. I need new reading glasses. Sigh. Thanks for the catch!
Posted by: Les Blatt | May 13, 2009 at 06:20 AM