All right, all right. It's overstatement. It's hype. We all know that. Even the editor of this anthology, scholar/publisher/bookstore owner/mystery maven Otto Penzler, admits it:
Attempting to compile any list of the best of anything is inevitably an exercise doomed to failure. Quite naturally, and properly, the immediate response on seeing the phrase "the best of" is, "Oh, really? Says who?"
All that said, Penzler's anthology, "The 50 Greatest Mysteries of All Time", really does contain 50 excellent stories. There are mysteries of every kind - classics, hard-boiled, psychological, cozies, modern masters, you name it, in a book that stretches chronologically from Edgar Allan Poe writing in 1844 to Elmore Leonard writing in 1999. It's the subject of this week's review on our podcast, and you can listen to it here. Check it out. If you like mysteries of any kind, you're going to find something to enjoy here - and you just may meet some new authors you hadn't tried before.
(Updated to fix typo)
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.